@glowbyleaa on TikTok

The beauty industry is changing as makeup influencers outpace legacy brands in social media presence.

New data shows there is a 50-million-follower gap between TikTok and Instagram.

By evaluating the total numbers for each influencer and each brand across Instagram and TikTok, CBJ Star has found that online personalities had a combined following of over 115 million, while legacy labels had only 64.3 million followers.

This total reveals a 50.7 million-followers gap, suggesting that while traditional enterprises have a long-term audience, content creators dominate customers’ online presence.

The impact of newer cosmetologists on social media reach and engagement is undeniable.

Collectively, these online creators boast a combined following of over 524 million followers, far exceeding that of traditional cosmetic lines.

Lea, 20, a makeup content creator and beauty advisor at Kiko Milano on TikTok, from Switzerland, explains why she believes creators are outperforming traditional labels.

Lea, 20, a beauty content creator and cosmetic sales advisor from Switzerland

Lea said:

“Because creators have a direct and personal connection with their audience.”

“The content feels more genuine and less like traditional advertising.”

“It also allows brands to communicate their message in a more targeted and relatable way.”

When it comes to sparking conversations, online bloggers are nearly 12 times more effective.

On TikTok, they average over 5,700 comments per post, whereas legacy groups like Revlon and Mac generate approximately 487.

The engagement rate data was taken from the social media analytics tracker, Social Insider.

Anisa, a marketing co-ordinator at Nottingham Trent University who also runs her own beauty business, considers whether the era of the faceless brand is over.

She said: “I wouldn’t say it’s over, but it’s definitely evolving.”

“Consumers still expect a level of polish from established brands as that’s part of what gives them that credibility.”

“What’s changed is the expectation of accessibility.”

A notable example of a traditional brand with strong engagement is L’Oréal Paris. With over 1.48 million followers on TikTok, it exceeds the follower count of many influencer accounts.

Yet, despite its large following, L’Oréal’s posts generate an average of 86 comments per post.

While the company’s engagement is impressive for a legacy brand, it remains much lower than that of influencers’.

Anisa comments on the lack of engagement beauty giants receive.

Anisa said, “In today’s landscape, being niche and loved is far more powerful.”

“A niche audience typically has higher intent, they’re more invested, trust your expertise, and are far more likely to engage and convert into repeat customers.

“It also creates a sense of exclusivity, which can increase perceived value.

“From a business perspective, this kind of loyalty is more sustainable.

“It’s easier to grow from a strong, engaged core audience than to try to activate a large but passive following.”

The metrics reflect a new reality in the beauty industry: while heritage staples like L’Oréal still command vast audiences and significant engagement, online beauticians are setting a new standard for interaction.

Their ability to generate likes, comments, and shares at such high rates continues to give them a major advantage in shaping consumer discourse.

Anisa said: “That level of familiarity builds trust in a way that traditional brands often struggle to replicate, because they’re not built around a single, consistent voice or personality.”

This evolving landscape signals a shift in how companies reach and engage their audience.

For consumers, it means more personalised and relatable content that influences purchasing decisions.

For brands, embracing influencer partnerships and authentic storytelling will be crucial to staying relevant.

As Lea notes from her experience as a beauty creator and building an online community:

“I pay close attention to feedback, comments, and messages.

“A lot of my content is inspired directly by my audience’s questions and needs, which makes it more relevant and personal.”

Her words reflect a broader truth: genuine connection and responsiveness are key to building trust and loyalty.

As social media continues to shape consumer preferences, companies that prioritise authenticity and community engagement will thrive in the future of beauty marketing.