
Premier League xG stats have been accurate within one goal 42 times in the past decade, CBJ Star has found.
The data spans 320 teams, with 13 per cent of them being correctly predicted within a single goal across a 38-game season.
And the accuracy remains strong when looking at how often teams are correctly projected within five goals.
That is 165 of the 320 teams, over 50 per cent.
This is despite many fans being reluctant to take notice of the stat.
xG (expected goals) is calculated by assigning each shot a probability between 0 and 1 of becoming a goal, based on historical data.
A penalty has an xG value of 0.76-0.79 depending on the source.
Understat and FotMob are two of the market leaders in xG, but the latter actually uses Opta for their projections.
FotMob software developer, Jos, said: “FotMob uses xG from Opta, not our own model.
“There isn’t really a stance internally on xG’s benefits and accuracy.
“It’s more that xG is a useful stat to show in the app and let users interpret it themselves.”
The data shows how accurate the models can be.
In 2020/21, Understat’s projections had West Brom scoring 0.03 fewer goals than they actually scored.
While a season later, FotMob predicted Aston Villa to score just 0.01 more goals than in reality.
And across all available seasons, neither data provider has been more than seven goals out when calculating the average difference between projected goals and actual goals for all 20 clubs.
The data is also accurate on a player level.
Neither source has been more than four goals out when calculating the same average but for individual players.
And in the five seasons in which both sources have data available, they have never been more than 0.4 out from each other’s projections.
One team with a unique history with xG is Brighton.
For a period, the Seagulls were serial xG underperformers.
In all seven seasons spanning 2017-2024, Brighton were predicted by Understat to score more goals than they actually did.
And it was during Graham Potter’s reign that the club underperformed the most.
During Potter’s three full seasons on the south coast, his side were projected to score 8.42, 13.82 and 7.57 more goals than they actually did.
The club finished 15th and 16th in his first two campaigns, despite the data having them in the top half for xG in the latter season.
Brighton finished 9th in Potter’s final full campaign, their highest ever top flight finish at the time.
Had the club not kept their faith in Potter and their xG numbers, relegation may have been on the cards.
But some fans are still reluctant to take much notice of it.
Tim Carder, a spokesperson for the Brighton & Hove Albion Supporters’ Club, said: “I tend to think it is very mildly interesting but no more than that.
“I was not aware of the team’s xG under Potter.
“If I had been aware, it would not have reassured me of the club’s prospects of avoiding relegation.
“Goals decide matches, not xG.”

Since then, the Seagulls have cemented themselves as midtable regulars, even qualifying for Europe for the first time in their history in 2022/23.
They are an example of what a club can become if xG is trusted, but Carder still believes the abilities of a manager are vital.
He said: “If being data-driven gives us an edge over other clubs then yes I would be proud of that, and probably am.
“But as an outsider to the club’s inner workings, I might regard the abilities of the manager/head coach as just as important if not more so.
“I certainly believe that our qualification for European competition was down to the head coach making the most of good players that may or may not have been identified and signed as a result of data-driven approach by the club.”
Brighton rely heavily on data like xG for their recruitment.
Their approach has unearthed players from all over the world and has allowed the club to sell a player for £50m+ in four of the last five seasons.
Club owner Tony Bloom is a professional sports gambler and has instilled the data mindset on the south coast.
And for some, the approach makes sense.
Brighton fan of 48 years, Philippa Hudson, said: “I have seen the many changes in football and the huge expansion in data within the game – both in recruitment and in stats surrounding the matches.
“I am very proud of the way we as a club use data to enhance our recruitment in particular.”
Philippa Hudson, Brighton fan
“As a so-called smaller club within the Premier League it is vital to use any system or additional advantage we can to compete with the bigger clubs and in particular the ‘Big Six’ who have vastly superior finances.”









